financial ignorance
Personal Finance

At A Certain Point, Intentional Financial Ignorance Is Bliss

OK, dummy, what have the past few months taught you about risk tolerance, FOMO, and investing? When it comes to finances, you need some sort of plan, and ignorance is most certainly not bliss for those first starting out and trying to figure out what to do with their money. But intentional financial ignorance is blissful indeed. Once solutions are found to the common personal finance problems, there comes a point when taking further action becomes more of a hinderance to investing returns. At that point, a set and forget approach remains the key to financial success and personal well-being.

Reflections on a speculative relapse

If you’ve been following along, I’ve recently deviated from reasonably sound musings toward the rantings of a madman, investing in meme stocks and, most recently, plunging into the hottest ETF on the planet. I allocated about 3% of my assets toward the ever-popular ARK funds, pretty near the absolute top. Those investments have received a significant haircut in the neighborhood of a 25% loss. Buy high, sell low baby (I’m not actually selling them).

As a hobby, I follow the markets pretty closely, despite my lack of classical training geared toward doing so. I am interested enough in personal finance to sporadically write blogs about money on the internet. As such, I am not immune to the disease of a good speculative frenzy. As Warren Buffet has said, bubbles happen because people see that the “guy next door, who they know is dumber than they are, is getting rich and they aren’t.” I might not be smarter than the guy next door, but I’m at least paying more attention. In this case, that inattention is what gives him the edge.

Intentional financial ignorance is bliss

You don’t want to be in a position of complete ignorance, with no Earthly idea what funds your 401k is invested in, or what a Roth IRA is, or how much you’re spending, etc. There are millions of people for whom ignorance is a very costly endeavor. But once a basic understanding of your financial situation is established, and automatic investments into low-cost funds are set, the average schmuck like me is best off re-acquainting themselves with the comforts of the weighted blanked that is sweet, sweet ignorance.

By tinkering with my own investment accounts, I’ve done myself more harm than good over the last few months. Not enough to mess with my timeline in any meaningful way—though I might have cost myself an extra week of work at some point 15 years from now—but enough for some temporary heartburn and anxiety along the way.  

When the market took a tumble at just about this time last year, it wasn’t fun to watch the numbers on my net worth dwindle, but I didn’t lose a second of sleep. My near 100% indexed funds were simply doing what the market is designed to do. Sometimes it goes up, sometimes it goes down. Decades of historic returns tell me that it will indeed go up again, and that I should reload with any spare gun powder I have lying around when it does take its natural nosedives.

But now, anything that I do outside of VTSAX carries with it the opportunity cost of not simply indexing. Now that I know better, I should know better. Or risk taking a 25% loss (as opposed to a percentage point or two) with highly volatile funds.

Tripling down on VTSAX

You’ll see plenty of blog posts and Boglehead threads extoling the virtues index investing and VTSAX, and rightfully so. I’ve done it plenty myself and will continue to do so. A super low-cost option that historically outperforms actively managed funds? Of course that’s the right path for 99.9% of people. But, human nature being what it is, and speculative euphoria being the drug of choice, it’s easy to look upon this last decade of paltry 15% returns (sarcastic emphasis on paltry) in search of the overnight 10x-ers that keep popping up on the news.

I’m not here to provide any new information. Merely, I aim to remind myself and others, as I’ve already reminded myself and ignored, about the virtues of passive investing. This time, I highlight this investing approaching not so much for the financial sense it makes, but rather the emotional one. 

From an economic sense, there isn’t much of an argument over the long term against market-tracking index funds. Outliers are prevalent in a bull market such as this, though. Some active managers and individual investors alike will indeed beat the market over time. But Lordy, I am not one of them.

Knowing how hard I’ve worked for money, and how hard it can be to come by, it is torture to watch it dwindle away in large quantities. Especially when that wound is self-inflicted. And especially when the alternative is so easy and so obvious.

22 thoughts on “At A Certain Point, Intentional Financial Ignorance Is Bliss

  1. I think for the average person, index investing makes sense and financial ignorance is a bliss. Fomo is a real thing. I know people that are literally financial advisors that switched their strategy and got caught up. I would argue that the opposite of financial ignorance is needed though. People need more time to research, so they understand one month of market returns is too short of a time to react, to better understand their investments, and to recognize the kind of investors that don’t know what they are doing. The problem is that most people simply don’t have enough time. Because of their full time jobs that are not related to investing, and because of their busy lifestyles, there is not enough time to do proper research. So, then they react to a bunch of news because they don’t know what they are doing. If you have enough time, you can educate yourself and make informed decisions. But since most people don’t have enough time to research, and since the fluctuations bother them, and since they worry about short term net worth numbers too much, people get caught up and make decisions out of fomo and fear. If you are investing for 5 plus years and you understand what you own, you will look at pull backs as a good thing, and you will know fomo behaviour when you see it. Most investors should just buy the S&P, manage risk in percentages, and then not look at all. Your ARK ETF will likely be an outperformed in 5 years.

    1. Excellent points. Key part of the phrase for me is “at a certain point,” and I would agree that the majority of people are not yet at that point. Tinkering with investments and trying to get cute (largely based on news reports and other short term factors) often does more harm than good for someone who is heavily invested, especially an index investor like myself. Though I of course haven’t been touching my primary investments. Certainly, it’s imperative for everyone to take the time and get educated & invested, and then and only does ignorance become a positive trait in their investing (assuming automatic investments are being made).

      My time horizon for ARK remains 5-10 years, if not longer, but it’s always a gut punch to invest in something that immediately takes a dip. Time in the market beats timing the market, but an immediate 20% haircut can alter that when dealing with more concentrated assets like individual securities or thematic ETFs.

      It’s been interesting to learn about myself that FOMO is by far a bigger risk for me than Fear!

  2. I like the Warren Buffett quote and he has another quote “Rule No.1: Never lose money. Rule No.2: Never forget rule No.1” Too bad you lost money and at least you know index funds are the way to go. However, being attentive can hurt you like it did. However, it is much better than some who not being attentive it is hurting way more. Have to have balance. I know I enjoy watching the market but have never bought into a hype and plan to keep it that way, however, I do sometimes pick my own stock which is always fun but like you its always really small relative to the portfolio.

    1. Absolutely right–I think about that quote often. I think the temptation is always going to exist in bubbly times like these, and allocating a little play money is a good way to scratch the itch and buy yourself 10 more years of not second-guessing index funds.

  3. Right? Is my level of knowledge just enough to be considered “armed and dangerous”?. I have certainly outsmarted myself many times on my financial journey.

    I do think index investing is just another way to blindly follow the masses. And there is part of me that thinks we should be able to be successful doing what makes sense, instead of what everyone else does. It irks me, for example, that buying into an index means I have to buy the companies I hate in order to own the companies I believe in.

    But the masses have momentum. Executed poorly, being a contrarian is a recipe for disaster. So if you can’t beat ’em, join ’em?

    1. That’s a great point about index investing, especially as it pertains to investing in companies you don’t particularly like. While it is following the masses to an extent, it’s a mass that I tend to agree with on all sorts of money issues, and has worked exactly as promised in terms of results and peace of mind. Not until I start tinkering do I start giving myself anxiety over my money decisions. It might just be that I can’t make decisions for myself in any walk of life anymore haha. Losing 20-25% of an investment within the first few weeks doesn’t help either!

      I think that if I control the amounts that I’m playing with, and keep it separate (at least mentally) from my regular index investments, I’ll be able to continue to sleep soundly. But ultimately I’ve realized over and over again that index is simply the way for me.

  4. You have to trademark your response to Buffet’s bubble quote. That was profound:
    “I might not be smarter than the guy next door, but I’m at least paying more attention.” -IF
    Our children will be reading this in their future Personal Finance [online] textbooks.

    1. I find myself worse off than my dumb neighbor because I know just enough to think I’m in the know. When 80-90% of individual investors don’t outperform the market, why would I think I can? Back to the index fund pile for me haha

  5. Great reminder! We are the set it and forget it type mainly because life is so busy, we can’t keep a pulse on everything. But when we see those nose dives on our investment accounts, can’t help but wonder. But the market will do what the market will do, as you’ve said. And we’d definitely just make things worse by trying to course correct.

  6. fomo is real. you’re not the only one late to the bandwagon the past few months. remember the reader of mine who wanted to know how to start buying growth stocks? i had to go back and re-read my answer but averaging into those is probably best.

    believe me when i say my portfolio has taken a savage beating the past few weeks. i would say it is down 20-25% for individual stocks. it feels less bad when you have built up a big lead but still sucks. i hope it’s temporary and am not selling out of any of them. the bright spot is some of these growth names are on sale and may go on deeper discount in the coming weeks and months. will you be buying at these more reasonable prices or just to back to the vtsax 100%?

    1. Yeah in hindsight that would have been the right approach haha. I have averaged down a little bit and will have to continue to do so out of sheer stubbornness. My time horizon doesn’t change on ARK (5+ years) but volatility is a lot less fun on the way down, that’s for sure!

  7. I like the title of this post. That’s so true. For me, intentional ignorance to the news in general brings me bliss, but I can’t help myself and dutifully stuff myself with news…especially finance news. This makes it hard to set it and forget.

    I also learn by touching the stove unfortunately. The good thing is that you’re majority invested in the index funds. Nothing wrong with playing with a small amount as long as you’re ready to lose it. I took a punch to the belly too with my recent stock purchases, but I’m holding on…and I’ll force myself to buy some more even though it pains me, just because the market is down and there’s deals out there I may regret not getting in on down the road.

    1. That’s a great point–intentional ignorance can apply to many areas in life, and news consumption is a wonderful example. Haha I have been doing plenty of stove touching myself over the last few months. There’s one thing in saying I’m prepared to lose it, and another to actually lose it!

  8. A great reminder. To be perfectly honest, the main reason I blog and follow other personal finance blogs is to continually reinforce this thinking. It’s not really to learn much that’s new. I’m afraid that if I don’t keep reminding myself that I’m on a wise path, it’ll be too easy to jump on the latest bandwagon. You’re spot-on, and we can’t have enough reminders like this.

    1. That’s a great point. It is one of those things that just need to be constantly reinforced. I’ve learned I’m more of a hazard to myself in bull markets than bear markets. When things go south, I can preach staying the course just fine, but when I feel like I’m getting lapped in good times, I start trying to take shortcuts.

Leave a personal or impersonal comment